Letter

I haven't written anything recently because nothing much has inspired me to do so. So for those of you who are wanting and expecting some new words of wisdom from me I will post a letter of mine that was published in a philosophy magazine. The subject deals with pop-culture, which was the theme of the particular issue of the magazine I responded to. And the particular subject I responded to was about "Captain America".

Here is the letter:

As I was working away framing pictures I was also trying to frame a philosophical idea in my head. Framing pictures and framing ideas are similar activities: both need boundaries to help define and animate them. The idea I was trying to animate has to do with Major Todd A. Burkardt's article 'Operation Rebirth: Captain America and the Ethics of Enhancement' in Issue 64. Burkardt portrays Captain America as an individual, but his creator might have intended him to represent all Americans. In other words, Captain America is symbolic and representative of the exceptionalism of America, in terms of its focus on freedom and liberty for all.

I think Kant would have liked the representation of Captain America as emblematic of peace, because he wanted to see people and nations live in peace. And Kant was right to speculate that democracies needn't go to war with each other. Creating enhance soldiers, as Burhardt advocates, would be counterproductive to the world's continuing efforts through agencies like the UN to make war a thing of the past. Creating enhanced soldiers would send the wrong message, certainly not one of peace. Instead we should work to enhance democracy so that countries don't go to war with each other, thus having no need for enhance soldiers. Enhanced soldiers, like any soldier, can't impose democracy, as we have recently learned with Iraq.